Email Us

Key Differences between Ball Grid Array Assembly and Traditional PCB Assembly

Table of Content [Hide]

    As electronic devices continue to become smaller, faster, and more complex, the methods used to assemble printed circuit boards (PCBs) have evolved significantly. One of the most advanced and efficient technologies today is Ball Grid Array (BGA) assembly. Compared to traditional PCB assembly, BGA offers enhanced performance, higher reliability, and improved heat dissipation.


    At GreensTone, we specialize in providing high-quality BGA PCB assembly services, delivering precision, reliability, and innovation for applications across industries—from smart home systems and EV chargers to medical and communication devices. In this article, we’ll explore the key differences between BGA assembly and traditional PCB assembly, and why choosing the right method can greatly impact your product’s performance.

    1. Packaging Design and Structure


    Traditional PCB assembly typically uses packages such as DIP (Dual Inline Package), QFP (Quad Flat Package), or SOIC (Small Outline IC), where component leads extend from the sides and are soldered to the PCB pads.


    BGA assembly, on the other hand, uses an array of tiny solder balls located on the underside of the package instead of protruding leads. These solder balls serve as both the mechanical and electrical connection points.


    Advantages of BGA design:

    • Higher component density — ideal for compact devices.

    • Shorter signal paths — improving electrical performance.

    • Better heat dissipation through uniform contact across the board.


    GreensTone’s precision engineering ensures perfect solder ball alignment and placement accuracy, resulting in consistent and robust BGA connections.

    2. Assembly Process


    Traditional PCB assembly often relies on through-hole or surface mount (SMT) technology using leaded components. Soldering is performed manually or via wave soldering machines.


    In BGA PCB assembly, components are placed using automated pick-and-place machines, followed by reflow soldering, where the entire board is heated to melt and solidify the solder balls beneath the component.


    Key process differences:

    AspectTraditional PCB AssemblyBall Grid Array Assembly
    Mounting TypeLeaded or Surface MountSurface Mount with solder balls
    Soldering MethodWave or Hand SolderingReflow Soldering
    InspectionVisual / AOI3D X-ray Inspection
    Automation LevelMediumHigh


    At GreensTone, we use high-precision SMT equipment and nitrogen-controlled reflow ovens to ensure even solder reflow and eliminate oxidation during the heating process.

    3. Reliability and Electrical Performance


    BGA assemblies are known for superior electrical performance and mechanical reliability. The short, uniform interconnections reduce signal distortion and resistance. Meanwhile, traditional leaded packages can introduce longer signal paths, resulting in slower transmission and potential interference.


    Moreover, BGA’s large number of contact points distributes stress evenly, minimizing the risk of solder joint cracking.


    GreensTone ensures all assemblies comply with IPC-A-610 Class 3 standards, meeting the stringent requirements of high-reliability industries such as medical, communication, and automotive electronics.

    4. Inspection and Quality Control


    Inspecting solder joints in traditional PCB assembly is straightforward since leads are visible. Technicians can rely on visual inspection or AOI systems to identify defects.


    In contrast, BGA solder joints are hidden beneath the component, making inspection more complex. GreensTone overcomes this challenge with 3D X-ray inspection (AXI) and CT analysis to detect hidden defects such as voids, bridging, or insufficient soldering.


    This advanced inspection ensures every BGA connection meets performance expectations before delivery.

    5. Rework and Repair Complexity


    In traditional PCB assembly, defective joints can be reworked easily using soldering irons or hot-air tools.


    BGA rework, however, requires specialized equipment and skills. Each component must be carefully heated and lifted without damaging adjacent components or the PCB substrate. GreensTone’s rework technicians use infrared BGA rework stations and precision-controlled hot air systems to restore full functionality while maintaining product integrity.


    Our experience in BGA reballing and repair allows us to handle complex rework processes effectively and safely.

    6. Thermal and Mechanical Performance


    BGA assemblies provide excellent thermal conductivity because the solder balls create multiple direct paths for heat transfer between the chip and the PCB. This makes them ideal for high-power or high-frequency applications, such as automotive controllers and 5G communication modules.


    Traditional assemblies, in contrast, rely on fewer contact points, leading to less efficient heat dissipation.


    At GreensTone, we optimize reflow profiles and material selection to maximize both thermal performance and long-term reliability.

    7. Cost Considerations


    While BGA assembly involves higher upfront costs for equipment and inspection, it reduces costs in the long term through:

    • Higher component density (smaller boards)

    • Improved reliability (fewer failures)

    • Enhanced performance (fewer redesigns)


    Traditional assemblies may appear cheaper initially but can incur greater costs in rework, testing, and field failures over time.


    By leveraging GreensTone’s automated production lines, customers benefit from both cost efficiency and exceptional quality assurance.

    8. Applications in Modern Electronics


    BGA assembly dominates in high-performance and miniaturized electronics, including:

    • EV chargers and power modules

    • Smart home systems and IoT devices

    • Medical monitoring equipment

    • Industrial control and communication modules


    Traditional PCB assembly, while still common in simpler or low-volume products, is gradually being replaced in high-end applications due to the superior electrical and mechanical advantages of BGA technology.

    Conclusion


    The choice between Ball Grid Array assembly and traditional PCB assembly depends on your project’s requirements for performance, reliability, and density. However, for most modern electronic devices, BGA technology clearly delivers superior results.


    At GreensTone, we bring together state-of-the-art SMT facilities, IPC-certified engineers, and a robust quality management system to provide world-class BGA PCB assembly services. Our commitment to precision and reliability ensures every assembly performs flawlessly, even in the most demanding environments.


    References

    NEXT: No information


    Hot Electronic Contract Manufacturing Services
    Other Electrical Contract Manufacturing News
    0086-755-23215983-2006
    4F B5 XuJingChang Industry Zone HaoYe Rd. No.39, XinHe Street, FuYong District, Shenzhen, China